Celebrating 50+ Years of Real Estate on

Fishers Island

2025 Rentals

1974 – 2025

Click Here to view a map of the properties

Mystic Isle Realty

About Us

Mystic Isle realty has been a family owned and operated full service real estate firm on Fishers Island, NY for over 50 years. We do our utmost to provide professional and experienced advice to those interested in buying, selling or renting on the Island or simply in discussing the background of this very special place. You are invited to explore our current offerings, or add your contact information to our email list .
Of course for specifics inquiries we can be reached anytime by phone, text or email.

Click on the following for – Recently Sold Properties

Click on the following  FI.NET for all information on the island.

Best, Jim, Ace and Meg

Prev
Next


Sale Pending

1950 Equestrian Ave. – Sale Pending

• Beds: 5
• Baths: 3

Exclusive Listing

For Sale

Tabor Fields – 1880 Isabella Beach Rd.

• $4,500,000

• Beds: 5
• Baths: 5

Exclusive Listing

For Sale

Private

Waterfront

“ScotFree” – West End, 6 BR, 4.5 BA, Private Dock

• $4,950,000

• Beds: 6
• Baths: 4 1/2
• 2.2 Acres (Two Lots)

For Sale

Clay Point Road Undeveloped Lot – Waterviews

• $2,350,000

Exclusive Listing

For Sale

1027 Castle Road

• $2,750,000

• Beds: 5
• Baths: 3.5

MIR SOP