Sold Properties
119 Castle Road – SOLD
September 2023
119 Castle Road Fishers Island, NY SOLD 11/30/23 Nestled within a serene and private setting, this well-maintained four-bedroom house boasts elevated water views in two directions: a panoramic northern vista overlooking East Harbor and a sweeping southern perspective across Long Island Sound. Originally designed by Jim Righter of Boston firm Albert, Righter and Tittman in
Read more2428 Isabella Beach Rd. – SOLD – 9/23
September 2023
Sold 9/12/23 3 BR’s, 3.5 Baths, 3 Lots
Read more806 Wilderness Point Rd. 8/9/23
August 2023
Direct Waterfront, Private, 5 BR, 5.5 Bath, Pool, West End
Read more328 Ave. B, Renovated in 2022 – SOLD 6/15/23
April 2023
Located on a quiet, dead-end street on the West End, 328 Ave B is an easily navigated single-story home a short walk from Dock Beach. 3 BR, 2 Bath, Heat / A/C, fully renovated.
Read more“Quail Hill” – SOLD 11/22/22
November 2022
Quail Hill Located on approximately .98 acres on the West End with stunning views overlooking the Hay Harbor Golf Course, down South Beach, with Race Rock Lighthouse and the Race beyond. This classic, summer-style cottage was built in 1897 and has a covered porch that allows one to enjoy, in my opinion, some of the
Read more“Out of Bounds” – 7 BR’s, Pool, SOLD 7/6/22
July 2022
“Out of Bounds” SOLD – 7/6/22 Fishers Island, NY
Read more
Two East End Undeveloped Lot – SOLD
May 2022
East End Two Undeveloped Lots for Sale SOLD The two lots have a combined 6.5+ acres and has direct water frontage on Barleyfield Pond. The pond lot would have distant views of the pond and Block Island Sound.
Read moreMadeline Avenue Lot – SOLD
March 2022
Located on the West End this .30 of an acre lot has West Harbor water views and is within a quick walk to Dock Beach or the Fishers Island Yacht Club. The lot is on a quiet street and one could build a nice 3/4 bedroom house and be comfortable for many years. SOLD 3/7/22
Read moreSOLD – “Troll Haugen” 4BR, water views, East End
December 2021
SOLD – 12/21 4BR and 3 Bath Elevated with distant water views.
Read moreSOLD – Montauk Ave 10 BR w/ Cottage
December 2021
[vc_row][vc_column][vc_column_text]SOLD – 12/21 Montauk Ave. Fishers Island, NY Located on the West End, this classic house sits high on the hill with distant views of West Harbor. The house faces North, and the main floor has a large, solid porch wrapping around half of the house and a rolling grass yard. The second floor also
Read moreTwo East End Undeveloped Lot – SOLD
November 2021
East End Two Undeveloped Lots for Sale SOLD The two lots have a combined 6.5+ acres and has direct water frontage on Barleyfield Pond. The pond lot would have distant views of the pond and Block Island Sound.
Read moreSwan Lake – SOLD
September 2021
SOLD 9/21 A gracious Fishers Island icon. Swan Lake is a venerable East end estate with a noteworthy history and ideal location, located on 4.32 +/- acres overlooking Barleyfield Pond / Cove and Block Island Sound beyond. This spectacular 6 bedroom large Tudor house was built in 1928 and renovated by the current owners in
Read more960 The Gloaming – 2 BR, West Harbor Views, SOLD 9/21
September 2021
960 The Gloaming 1000-9-9-9 (.38A)
Read more573 Halcyon A (Pool Lot) – SOLD 9/21
September 2021
573 Halcyon Two Properties- 1000-9-6-8.4 (3.12A) 1 BR with pool 1000-9-6-8.3 (2.9A) 2 BR
Read more573 Halcyon B (2 Bedroom Cottage)- SOLD 9/21
September 2021
573 Halcyon Two Properties- 1000-9-6-8.4 (3.12A) 1 BR with pool 1000-9-6-8.3 (2.9A) 2 BR
Read more
SOLD – 6 BR, West End, Great Views, Excellent Condition
May 2021
SOLD May, 2021 Fishers Island, NY
Read more
West Harbor 3 BR Cottage – SOLD
December 2020
SOLD (12/20) West Harbor Property 3 BR Cottage on the water with a dock 1 BR additional Cottage This 3 bedroom and 2 bathroom cottage located on the Peninsular with a fantastic porch as well as a screened-in dining area. The property looks west over the Harbor and has its own private dock.
Read moreSOLD- Fort Apartment (3B Co-op)
November 2020
SOLD 151 Whistler Avenue – Unit 3 (b) 11/3/20 1 / 2 BR and 1 Bathroom Third floor apartment in Fort Apartment building # 1000-009.00-10.00-009.002
Read moreSOLD – West End, 6 BR, West Harbor View
November 2020
Classic 6 BR West End Cottage with Harbor Views SOLD (11/20) Located on the West End, this classic 6 BR and four bathroom house sits elevated off Montauk Ave., with strong views looking North over West Harbor. The house has a generous and comfortable layout with a large updated kitchen, a lovely dining room, and
Read moreSOLD, Excellent Views, Mid-Island, 5 BR, 2 Lots
October 2020
SOLD October 2020 Located on the East End and just north of the driving range this fully renovated, approximately 4,000 sq. ft. the house has 5 bedrooms, and 4 bathrooms with spectacular elevated views over Fishers Island Sound. The property is very private and consists of two lots with a combined 5+ acres, the lower
Read more
3 BR off Ave. B. Sold 8/31/20
September 2020
Sold 8/31/20 To a very happy family who will live on the island year-round. Congrats.
Read moreWreck Island Overlook – SOLD
August 2020
This is perhaps the most striking undeveloped building lot remaining on Fishers Island, this 3.4-acre site enjoys completely unobstructed views of Block Island Sound and “Wreck Island” from a high southeasterly vantage point. With 338 feet of direct water frontage, the lot is beautifully contoured and provides an ideal and very logical building site that
Read more
Barleyfield – Great Views, Private, 2 Lots, 4 BR’s SOLD 6/5/20
June 2020
Barleyfield Located near the Big Club and on two lots (2.4 acre house lot and 2.54 acre undeveloped lot) with 4.9+ private acres. This four bedroom house has fantastic views over Barleyfield Cove and Block Island Sound, the house has 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, a fireplace and is winterized. There is a deck off the
Read moreCottage 12 Shingle Hill – Sold May 2020
May 2020
Located on Shingle Hill, 7 BR’s, good condition. Sold May 5, 2020
Read moreBrooks Point 6 BR w/ Pool
December 2019
SOLD 12/19 Mystic Isle was honored to represent the buyers.
Read more
Spectacular Property on Fishers Island Sound (SOLD 10/9/19)
October 2019
Fishers Island Sound Property Sold 10/9/19 Located on the East End and on the North side of the island with strong views looking West. This 5 bedroom and 3 bathroom house is private, well maintained and a friendly, comfortable home. Located on 3.5 acres off the Brooks Point Road with over 400 feet of direct
Read moreCentral West End Location 4 BR/ 3 Bath Well Maintained House – Sold 10/9/19
October 2019
[vc_row][vc_column][vc_column_text] Sold 10/9/19 Located near town and across from the St. John’s church and library this four bedrooms / three bath home is comfortable and well-appointed. The interior is spacious with an open floor plan and the three bedrooms upstairs each has an air conditioner window unit as well as a first-floor bedroom. The second
Read more
Red Barn Studio – SOLD Nov. 2018
November 2018
The Charlie Ferguson “Red Barn” Studio was sold in Nov. 2018.
Read moreBarlow Pond Road – Mid Island
September 2018
Sold September 2018 This 3 bedroom and 3 bathroom house was completed in 2008 and has had many new features added. The 3 bedrooms and two bathrooms are on the ground floor giving the second floor, a wonderful open space with a large kitchen / dining / living area, with distant water views looking south over
Read moreTop of the World
August 2018
Sold August 2018 Located on the East End, this private, cleared lot faces Northeast and has access from the Top of the World Road and then runs down to the Brooks Point Road. There are a few logical building sites, each with fantastic views looking NE over Fishers Island Sound, Latimer’s Lighthouse and Stonington, CT.
Read moreWilderness Point Lot
July 2018
A great piece of land located on Wilderness Point. This Point only has 7 homes off a private road and is a 5 minute drive to the center of Town and on the public side of the island. The property currently has a structure but is not up to current building code and would most
Read moreCommercial Property Sold
July 2018
Undeveloped Lot sold Jule 2018 located on the West End and near the grocery store. Evergreen Landscaping.
Read moreWest End Alpine Avenue
July 2018
Located on the West End on a quiet street with elevated views over West Harbor this 5-bedroom ranch style house is in great condition.
Read moreOverlooking Chocomount Cove
May 2018
Private with great views over Chocomount Cove and Block Island Sound. Winterized house on 5 acres with a cottage, garage, and access to Chocomount beach via a private path.
Read moreWest End 7BR
April 2018
Sold April 20, 2018. 7 BR, 5+ acres, Pool, Pool house, Great Condition
Read morePequot Point
February 2018
A very special property with 3.99 acres located on the far East End with direct water frontage, a pool and a well-maintained nine-bedroom house. The setting is private with large landscaped yards on both the road and water sides of the house and outstanding views over the water spanning from Watch Hill, RI to
Read moreChocomount Beach House
January 2018
Sold January 2018 Perhaps the premier waterfront location on Fishers Island, this 3.96+/- acre parcel with 322 feet of direct access to the east end of Chocomount Beach includes a delightfully stylish 5 bedroom and 4 bath “Beach House”. There is a large front yard with a path that leads to the beautiful beach. This
Read more
Two East End Beach Lots
October 2017
This Property Sold in November 2017 A Rare Opportunity Two Undeveloped East End Lots On the North Shore of the Island Video of the Beach July 2017 The first lot consists of 2.22 acres with over 200 feet of a private sandy beach. The back adjoining lot, which abuts the main road, is situated on
Read more
Extraordinary 6 Bedroom
June 2017
Magnificent Property Located on the West End situated high with tremendous views of West Harbor, Fishers Island Sound, the Dumplings and Flat Hammock, this prime 1.4 acre property has all the amenities you could want on Fishers Island. The six bedroom and six bathroom house was completed in 2002 with incredible detail and workmanship. The
Read moreNear Chocomount undeveloped lot
March 2017
This 1.8 acre undeveloped East End building site overlooks Chocomount Beach with expansive views of Long Island Sound and easy access to the beach proper. This beautiful location affords the opportunity to build on a site that already has much ground work completed with the Town of Southold for the permitting of a house. Survey and topographical studies
Read more
