119 Castle Road – 4BR, 5 Bath, 1 BR Cottage, Waterviews, Two lots

  • $5,250,000


119 Castle Road

Fishers Island, NY

Nestled within a serene and private setting, this well-maintained four-bedroom house boasts elevated water views in two directions: a panoramic northern vista overlooking East Harbor and a sweeping southern perspective across Long Island Sound. Originally designed by Jim Righter of Boston firm Albert, Righter and Tittman in 1986, with a thoughtful addition in 1990, the property has been impeccably maintained throughout the years.

The living spaces are designed to accommodate both comfort and entertainment. A spacious living room, thoughtfully designed for gatherings and adjacent to this, a grand dining room offers breathtaking views on either side, framing mealtime with natural beauty. The entrance to the house is equally inviting, leading guests through a bright and well-lit foyer that creates a warm welcome.

A primary bedroom on the second floor is a sanctuary, complete with his and her bathrooms, generous closet space, and practical storage solutions. The main floor features an additional primary bedroom with an en-suite bathroom and a generous walk-in closet. Both of these well-appointed bedrooms are graced with captivating water views that enhance the ambiance.

Completing the living arrangements are two additional bedrooms, each featuring its own bathroom and ample closet space. The property’s charm is further accentuated by a separate cottage, boasting its own living room, bedroom, and kitchen, as well as laundry facilities. Ideal for year-round living, the house is equipped with central air and heat, ensuring comfort regardless of the season. The timeless appeal of four working fireplaces—a feature gracing the primary bedrooms, living room, and dining room—is warm and welcoming during the winter months.

Situated off the bright sunroom and living room, amidst the meticulously landscaped gardens, there is a slate patio that overlooks the golf course and Long Island Sound in the distance. This outdoor haven offers not only a visual treat but also a tranquil, private retreat.

There is an additional undeveloped, buildable lot with fantastic views overlooking the 15th fairway and East Harbor, which is included with the sale of the property.

Listing Price: $5,250,000

Property Documents

Ogden 2019847 BND 11-12-2019 - Download


Land Area
2.97 +/- Acres - Two Lots
Updated on September 15, 2023 at 11:20 am

360° Virtual Tour

Compare listings

Jim Reid
  • Jim Reid