West End Sort By: Default Order Price - Low to High Price - High to Low Featured Listings First Date - Old to New Date - New to Old FI Overlook 2025 Great Location Water View “Quail Hill” – 5 BR, West End, Incredible Views – Rental Beds: 5Baths: 3.5 Sold Private Waterfront 4322 Oriental – SOLD 1/31/25 Beds: 6Baths: 4 1/22.2 Acres (Two Lots) Exclusive Listing Sold 252 Montauk Ave. – SOLD 11/21/24 Beds: 5Baths: 2 Sold Dock Water View Waterfront 4717 North Hill Rd. Sold 11/8/24 1950 Equestrian Ave. – SOLD 11/5/24 Beds: 5Baths: 3 Sold 1950 Equestrian Ave. – SOLD 11/5/24 Beds: 5Baths: 3 Sold SOLD 10/10/24 – 505 Ocean View Beds: 6Baths: 5.5 Coming Soon — 252 Montauk Ave. 5 BR on the West End with 1.3 Acres Sold SOLD – 8/24 Winthrop Ave. Lots 1852 Equestrian Ave. Jay Rd. 4 BR West End 5 BR, West Harbor water views, pool, private West End 5 BR near HHC Golf Course June Beds: 5Baths: 4 Sold West End Cottage – “SOLD” 1/22/24 Beds: 3Baths: 2 Sold SOLD – West End Undeveloped Lot on .91 acres Sold 806 Wilderness Point Rd. 8/9/23 Beds: 5Baths: 5.5 Water View The Reid Barn Beds: 3Baths: 3 Sold 328 Ave. B, Renovated in 2022 – SOLD 6/15/23 328 Ave. B, West End, Renovated in 2022 $1,400,000 West Harbor Entrance – 4 BR & 2 Bath, Outstanding Setting Beds: 4Baths: 2 Sold Water View “Quail Hill” – SOLD 11/22/22 Beds: 5Baths: 3.5 Exclusive Listing Great Location Water View “Quail Hill” – Sale Pending Beds: 5Baths: 3.5 West End, 4 BR, Near the Store July 2025 Great Location New Listing Water View “Quail Hill” – 5 BR, West End, Incredible Views $2,000,000 Beds: 5Baths: 3.5 Exclusive Listing Sold “Out of Bounds” – 7 BR’s, Pool, SOLD 7/6/22 Beds: 7Baths: 5.5 Private Waterfront “ScotFree” – West End, 6 BR, 4.5 BA, Private Dock $4,950,000 Beds: 6Baths: 4 1/22.2 Acres (Two Lots) Sold Shingle Hill Lot – SOLD 6/22 .56 Acres 3 BR, Water Views, Near Silver Eel Cove, Modern, A/C $10,500/Two Weeks Beds: 3Baths: 2 6 Bedroom on Hay Harbor 8/27 – 9/10 Exclusive Listing New Listing “Out of Bounds” – On the Hay Harbor Golf Course, 7 BR’s, Pool, Outstanding Views, Great Condition. $5,995,000 Beds: 7Baths: 5.5 Sold Madeline Avenue Lot – SOLD Overlooking Hay Harbor, 3 Bedroom, Private, Fantastic Setting 3 Bedroom on Hay Harbor – Renovated $9,000 Seahouse – 5 BR, Prime Property and Views – Two weeks in August $30,000/Two Weeks Beds: 5Baths: 5 Sold Water View SOLD – Montauk Ave 10 BR w/ Cottage Beds: 10Baths: 54500 Sq Ft +/- West Harbor 3 BR Cottage with a Dock Herrick 1 BR Cottage Sold 960 The Gloaming – 2 BR, West Harbor Views, SOLD 9/21 Sold 573 Halcyon A (Pool Lot) – SOLD 9/21 573 Halcyon – Two Properties Sold 573 Halcyon B (2 Bedroom Cottage)- SOLD 9/21 Sold SOLD – 6 BR, West End, Great Views, Excellent Condition Beds: 6Baths: 6 Full and 3 Half Water View West End, Water View – Montauk Ave. Beds: 10Baths: 54500 Sq Ft +/- Sold Private Water View SOLD April 2021 – Fourwinds, West End, 6 BR Beds: 6Baths: 6 West End, 4 BR, Near Town, Private, 2023 $15,000/Mid to late August Beds: 4Baths: 3 5BR, West End, Private, Pirates Cove, Dock Beds: 5/6Baths: 3.5 Incredible Property – 6 BR, West End, Great Views, 2 Lots Beds: 6Baths: 6 Full and 3 Half Sold Waterfront West Harbor 3 BR Cottage – SOLD Beds: 3Baths: 2 Bungalow 3 / Shingle Hill 4 BR – Newly Renovated Water View West End, 5 BR, West Harbor View Beds: 5Baths: 31.07 Acres Sold SOLD- Fort Apartment (3B Co-op) Sold Water View SOLD – West End, 6 BR, West Harbor View Beds: 6Baths: 41.07 Acres Sold SOLD 10/2/20 Beds: 5Baths: 2 Dock Water View Waterfront West End, 5 BR, Waterfront with Dock – New Price $3,950,000 VOIDED LISTING 10/2/20 $3,950,000 Beds: 5Baths: 31.32 Sold Water View Ferrywatch – SOLD 9/20 Beds: 5Baths: 3.54500 sqft Sold 3 BR off Ave. B. Sold 8/31/20 Sold Cottage 12 Shingle Hill – Sold May 2020 Sold Skye Hye – SOLD Nov. 2019 Sold Flounder In (SOLD 10/9/19) 1.91 Acres Sold Central West End Location 4 BR/ 3 Bath Well Maintained House – Sold 10/9/19 Beds: 4Baths: 31.13 Acres Sold West End 5 BR plus Cottage – SOLD May 2019 Sold SOLD March 2019 Sold Red Barn Studio – SOLD Nov. 2018 #75 Shingle Hill Cottage 1 for August 2020 Beds: 7Baths: 2.5 #28 West End 4 BR – June 2021 $4,500/per week Beds: 4Baths: 2 Point of Interest Elizabeth Field Airport Point of Interest Fishers Island Community Center Point of Interest Henry L Ferguson Museum Water View #78 Quail Hill – Overlooking Hay Harbor Golf Course Beds: 5Baths: 3.5 Point of Interest Mystic Isle Realty Office Point of Interest Ferry Dock Sold Waterfront Wilderness Point Lot SOLD July 2018 Sold Commercial Property Sold SOLD July 2018 Sold West End Alpine Avenue SOLD July 2018 Beds: 5Baths: 31500 sqft Featured Sold West End 7BR SOLD April 2018 Beds: 7 Sold Waterfront The Stable SOLD Nov 2017 Beds: 6Baths: 4.5 Sold 2 Bedroom Cottage SOLD Jun 2017 Beds: 2Baths: 2 Sold Waterfront Extraordinary 6 Bedroom SOLD Jun 2017 Beds: 6Baths: 6 Sold Clay Point Property SOLD Sept 2016 Sold Near Town SOLD Sept 2016 Sold West Harbor Dock and Lot SOLD Sept 2016 Sold West End Cottage SOLD Mar 2016 Point of Interest Sold Topper’s SOLD Feb 2016
