SOLD – Tidal Wave – 457 Equestrian Ave. 1/15/26

457 Equestrian Ave Fishers Island, NY 06390

Description

A Charming Mixed-Use Property Full of Character and Opportunity

SOLD 1/15/26

$995,000

A rare opportunity to own a versatile mixed-use property that perfectly blends commercial potential with residential living. Ideally situated in the center of town amid other thriving retail spaces, this property offers exceptional visibility, accessibility, and long-term investment value.

The property features three individual retail spaces, providing over 1,500± square feet of flexible commercial area. Each unit offers excellent street exposure and includes access to two half baths, making it ideal for boutique shops, offices, or service-based businesses.

Above the central commercial space sits a winterized two bedroom, one bath apartment encompassing approximately 600± square feet. Bright and inviting, it offers comfortable living quarters for an owner-occupant or the potential for rental income.

Set on 0.2 acres, the property features a sizeable backyard with potential for additional off-street parking. This address has been a commercial destination since the early 1900s. The Cape-style building, constructed in the 1950s with thoughtful additions added later, features updated plumbing and electrical systems.

 

Details

Bedrooms
2
Rooms
7
Bathrooms
3
Land Area
.20 Acres
Year Built
1960's
Tax
$7,250
Updated on January 15, 2026 at 12:15 pm

Floor Plans

Floor Plans

Description:

Compare listings

Compare
Jim Reid
  • Jim Reid