[Mystic Isle Realty]


We still have a great inventory of rentals available. Most vary from 2+ weeks to a month or the entire summer. There is a variety of price ranges, locations and size and the best thing to do is reach out to myself, Meg or Ace and we can assist. Not all rentals are on the website, so if there is anything in particular you are looking for please contact us.

Jim Reid 860.885.9880 or jimreid@mysticislerealty.com

Meg Atkin 203.470.3622 or mrafiny@gmail.com

Ace Ahrens 203.613.7181 or andrew.ahrens1@gmail.com

Filter Rentals
  Description Location
rental_thumbnail #13 Near Town and 5 bedrooms
Availability: Summer 2018 July or August
West End
rental_thumbnail #30 2 BR, Private, Brand New
Availability: July 18 to August 26 2018
Mid Island
rental_thumbnail Woodside Cabin
Availability: June, July (not 7/29 - 8/19), end of August, Sept.
East End near the four corners
rental_thumbnail #4 On West Harbor with Dock
Availability: June or until July 19 2018
West End - West Harbor
rental_thumbnail #91 Located next to Hay Harbor and on the water
Availability: July 2018
West End
rental_thumbnail Well maintained, 4 BR. August 2017
Availability: August 2018
West End, Private
rental_thumbnail Large House on Fishers Island Sound
Availability: 2-3 weeks in 2018
Brooks Point
rental_thumbnail Large House - East End
Availability: 6/29 to 7/17, 9/11 to 9/18th or 9/26 to 10/9 2018
Overlooking Middle Farms Pond
rental_thumbnail #67 Well Maintained 3 Bedroom, Private
Availability: August 1 through 9, and from August 20th through the fall 2018
East End views over the 8th hole
rental_thumbnail #15 Clay Point Road, 4BR
Availability: July or end of August 2018
Mid Island on the Clay Point Rd.
rental_thumbnail Outstanding Views
Availability: 8/11/18 to 8/29/18
East of Isabella and near Oyster Ponds
rental_thumbnail #66 West Harbor Views
Availability: 8/27 to LD 2018
West End
rental_thumbnail #5 The Pond House
Availability: June or July 2018
Located near Isabella Beach
rental_thumbnail #10 Water views - 3 Bedroom
Availability: 1st 2 weeks in July 2018
East End on Isabella Beach Road
rental_thumbnail #100 The Reid Barn
Availability: Spring 2018
West End across from the FIYC
rental_thumbnail Studio Apartment
Availability: Off Season
West End across from the FIYC
rental_thumbnail #101 Modern, Clean and Fresh, 4BR house w/ Cottage
Availability: Spring, June, August 20 into the Fall 2018
East End, Great views just pass the Big Club
rental_thumbnail #27 Cottage 12
Availability: June or Sept. 2018
Shingle Hill