Fishers Island – Two New Listings

Memorial Day 2018

It looks to be a fantastic Memorial Day weekend and we are very excited to announce these two new listings. So far, 2018 has been a strong year for Mystic Isle Realty, and overall, real estate on the island. Recently, we have been involved with three sales over 2mm and another over 1mm and additional properties are under contract. The rental market is once again record setting with many people wanting to visit and be part of this incredible is land.

Please be sure to take a look at the two new houses on the market below, and support the Sea Stretcher Marathon.

You can also visit our listings for other properties that are currently for sale.

Hope to see you on the island!
Bagley, Jim, Ace and Meg


Beautiful slopping landscape
Outstanding sunset views over Silver Eel Cove

Built in 2003, this very well maintained 5 BR house has amazing views looking West down Long Island Sound and over The Race. The setting and condition of the property makes this a great opportunity to own a bit of Fishers Island and enjoy it all year long.

Alpine Avenue

Newly refinished pool in front of the house
View of West Harbor from the pool

Alpine Ave. West Harbor Views is centrally located on the West End. Privately positioned at the end of Alpine Ave. and above Montauk Ave., it has views looking North over West Harbor. The house has 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, three living areas, a great deck, pool, and an oversized garage. Best of all – nothing needs to be done as it’s fully renovated!

Related posts

Bayview Cottage – West End, West Harbor views and near the FIYC

The Island is in full swing this busy summer on Fishers Island!

Continue reading

Thanksgiving 2017

Happy Thanksgiving! See upcoming events.

Continue reading

Fall 2017

Fall is in the air!

Continue reading